Off Season Plan Based on Current Rumors and Dipoto comments.

DavidGee24
Posts: 11895
Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 6:24 pm
Location: Phillips Ranch, CA

Re: Off Season Plan Based on Current Rumors and Dipoto comments.

Post by DavidGee24 » Fri Nov 13, 2026 5:29 pm

Seattle or Bust wrote: ↑
Fri Nov 13, 2026 1:39 am
1) I guarantee you nobody in baseball really thinks Chapman's bat is "cooked" given a poor May in 2026. Nobody is asking Chapman to be a .900 or even .800 OPS hitter. If he's a slightly above league average bat with + defense (which he's been every year other than an injury riddled '26) and the M's could pay him a modest salary per year then you take it given how bleak the current position is. Nothing says he can't do that with the bat.
In being fair and seeing both sides of the argument, I looked up his career stats at T-Mobile Park and :shock: .173/.246/.266 I didn't realize he was that bad either, but I think it's safe to say we should pass on him.
Seattle or Bust wrote: ↑
Fri Nov 13, 2026 1:39 am
Nolan Arenado put up a .666 OPS year in '25... he dropped an .806 OPS 3.4 WAR year in '26. In a post after Arenado was traded... you said you were glad the M's didn't sign him when Darren alerted you of his .666 OPS.
You...ARE aware that he did that playing half his games in Arizona, right? He actually was decent on the road (.783 OPS), but change "Arizona" to "Seattle" and that .806 overall drops like a rock. He's only played 15 games in his career at T-Mobile, but :shock: .131/.154/.180 I'll say it again: I'm glad the Mariners didn't acquire him and you should be too.
Seattle or Bust wrote: ↑
Fri Nov 13, 2026 1:39 am
Another, "if DavidGee says so" moment. There is a difference between 3 and 4 years of control. It's called one year and I guarantee you it's compelling to have an extra year of control. And again, you called Hancock cooked over and over... "okay, it's NOW official, Hancock's career is over." "This is 3 bad seasons in a row. Gotta cut bait and run." "Let's face it, Hancock sucks. He's in his third season and he's just getting worse. Too bad hes killed his trade values, the best we can do is stick him in the bullpen and hope he shines there." ... so you already have a history of giving up on a player and now you're crediting me for including an "above average" pitcher "for once" in a trade? The same guy you would have sent home and made of me for adding in trades in proposals years prior?
I see that you conveniently left out the part where the "3" is for a 23 year-old and the "4" is for a 27 year-old. It's not particularly compelling in this case. And what does what I said about Hancock a year ago have to do with anything? The weirdoness of you devoting your time to chasing down old posts notwithstanding, I even admitted that Hancock turned it around this season, during the season and in this thread. Once in a while it happens for a player and as a Mariner fan I'm happy to see it. I don't want these guys to continue to fail. However, that has nothing to do with whether or not it's a good trade for the Cards to trade Walker for him. It could possibly happen and I'd feel good about it, I just think that at this point we'd get the better end of a deal like that so it would be surprising if it did happen.
Seattle or Bust wrote: ↑
Fri Nov 13, 2026 1:39 am
Again, who knows how much his injury played a part in the reduced K rate. I'm not ready to give up on really good players the second they show a decline in an area... especially coming off an injury.

$7M is a cheap for a veteran reliever of his pedigree.
Again, I'm not totally against acquiring pitchers like that, but you have to remember that you're committing precious spots in your bullpen to these two, so you'd better feel very confident that they're going to perform as opposed to taking flyers.

DavidGee24
Posts: 11895
Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 6:24 pm
Location: Phillips Ranch, CA

Re: Off Season Plan Based on Current Rumors and Dipoto comments.

Post by DavidGee24 » Fri Nov 13, 2026 5:39 pm

D-train wrote: ↑
Fri Nov 13, 2026 5:26 pm
Not trying to dunk on you here at all. I was cleaning up my bookmarks and come across this. We have all been wrong many times. I had totally forgot I had saved it and hadn't seen it since. He made $23.5M that 1st season with the Dodgers.

https://marinertalk.com/viewtopic.php?f ... 20#p251155
Is this one of those "Rules For Thee But Not For Me" SoBisms? :lol: Hey, I'll admit that I'm wrong on occasion, although that only happens once every two or three years and it'll usually be on purpose just so that I can remember what it feels like. :D

Seattle or Bust
Posts: 12133
Joined: Wed Mar 09, 2022 7:09 pm

Re: Off Season Plan Based on Current Rumors and Dipoto comments.

Post by Seattle or Bust » Sat Nov 14, 2026 7:02 pm

DavidGee24 wrote: ↑
Fri Nov 13, 2026 5:29 pm
Seattle or Bust wrote: ↑
Fri Nov 13, 2026 1:39 am
1) I guarantee you nobody in baseball really thinks Chapman's bat is "cooked" given a poor May in 2026. Nobody is asking Chapman to be a .900 or even .800 OPS hitter. If he's a slightly above league average bat with + defense (which he's been every year other than an injury riddled '26) and the M's could pay him a modest salary per year then you take it given how bleak the current position is. Nothing says he can't do that with the bat.
In being fair and seeing both sides of the argument, I looked up his career stats at T-Mobile Park and :shock: .173/.246/.266 I didn't realize he was that bad either, but I think it's safe to say we should pass on him.
Seattle or Bust wrote: ↑
Fri Nov 13, 2026 1:39 am
Nolan Arenado put up a .666 OPS year in '25... he dropped an .806 OPS 3.4 WAR year in '26. In a post after Arenado was traded... you said you were glad the M's didn't sign him when Darren alerted you of his .666 OPS.
You...ARE aware that he did that playing half his games in Arizona, right? He actually was decent on the road (.783 OPS), but change "Arizona" to "Seattle" and that .806 overall drops like a rock. He's only played 15 games in his career at T-Mobile, but :shock: .131/.154/.180 I'll say it again: I'm glad the Mariners didn't acquire him and you should be too.
Seattle or Bust wrote: ↑
Fri Nov 13, 2026 1:39 am
Another, "if DavidGee says so" moment. There is a difference between 3 and 4 years of control. It's called one year and I guarantee you it's compelling to have an extra year of control. And again, you called Hancock cooked over and over... "okay, it's NOW official, Hancock's career is over." "This is 3 bad seasons in a row. Gotta cut bait and run." "Let's face it, Hancock sucks. He's in his third season and he's just getting worse. Too bad hes killed his trade values, the best we can do is stick him in the bullpen and hope he shines there." ... so you already have a history of giving up on a player and now you're crediting me for including an "above average" pitcher "for once" in a trade? The same guy you would have sent home and made of me for adding in trades in proposals years prior?
I see that you conveniently left out the part where the "3" is for a 23 year-old and the "4" is for a 27 year-old. It's not particularly compelling in this case. And what does what I said about Hancock a year ago have to do with anything? The weirdoness of you devoting your time to chasing down old posts notwithstanding, I even admitted that Hancock turned it around this season, during the season and in this thread. Once in a while it happens for a player and as a Mariner fan I'm happy to see it. I don't want these guys to continue to fail. However, that has nothing to do with whether or not it's a good trade for the Cards to trade Walker for him. It could possibly happen and I'd feel good about it, I just think that at this point we'd get the better end of a deal like that so it would be surprising if it did happen.
Seattle or Bust wrote: ↑
Fri Nov 13, 2026 1:39 am
Again, who knows how much his injury played a part in the reduced K rate. I'm not ready to give up on really good players the second they show a decline in an area... especially coming off an injury.

$7M is a cheap for a veteran reliever of his pedigree.
Again, I'm not totally against acquiring pitchers like that, but you have to remember that you're committing precious spots in your bullpen to these two, so you'd better feel very confident that they're going to perform as opposed to taking flyers.
I'm frankly tired about going around in circles with you.

1) You have often been wrong about the capital it's going to take to acquire players. The evidence is there in multiple threads that after the Mariners complete trades you're often dumbfounded. The Naylor, Geno, and Castillo trades are all evidence of this. How many times did I say Castillo could be traded and you mocked me? How many?

And your response was, "well it's not my fault the White Sox GM is such a moron." :roll: :roll: :roll:

2) You are often wrong about players and their eventual performance. That is why I'm highlighting what you said about Hancock and Arenado. So your evaluation in calling players "cooked" has to be in question because we have evidence of players turning it around after you've claimed they have no future in the sport.

3) Again, you never put forward any original ideas of your own. Make a plan numb nuts. You're sure good (not really...) at critiquing others but never put your own ass on the line. Well, it's because you're a narcissist... so the thought of being exposed for how little you actually know is terrifying.

DavidGee24
Posts: 11895
Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 6:24 pm
Location: Phillips Ranch, CA

Re: Off Season Plan Based on Current Rumors and Dipoto comments.

Post by DavidGee24 » Sat Nov 14, 2026 11:33 pm

Seattle or Bust wrote: ↑
Sat Nov 14, 2026 7:02 pm
I'm frankly tired about going around in circles with you.

1) You have often been wrong about the capital it's going to take to acquire players. The evidence is there in multiple threads that after the Mariners complete trades you're often dumbfounded. The Naylor, Geno, and Castillo trades are all evidence of this. How many times did I say Castillo could be traded and you mocked me? How many?

And your response was, "well it's not my fault the White Sox GM is such a moron." :roll: :roll: :roll:

2) You are often wrong about players and their eventual performance. That is why I'm highlighting what you said about Hancock and Arenado. So your evaluation in calling players "cooked" has to be in question because we have evidence of players turning it around after you've claimed they have no future in the sport.

3) Again, you never put forward any original ideas of your own. Make a plan numb nuts. You're sure good (not really...) at critiquing others but never put your own ass on the line. Well, it's because you're a narcissist... so the thought of being exposed for how little you actually know is terrifying.
You go in circles because you're a self-absorbed Libtard and can't handle dissenting opinions, much like you are in the Politics Forum.

And also very dishonest. I never said that Suarez, Naylor and Castillo couldn't be traded. Expressing surprise at the low cost is not the same thing. That's you changing the narrative, much like you do in the Politics Forum.

I'm rarely wrong about players' performance and we're not including Arenado. That's just you flat-out lying, much like you do in the Politics Forum.

Also, I was the one who called you the narcissist first and you're projecting...much like you do in the Politics Forum.

Want a plan? Okay, here's one. Make every effort to sign Sato. Make every effort to sign Suzuki and if doesn't happen, offer Kirby or Hancock for a good RH outfielder like Walker as you mentioned even though other players might need to be involved. Try and sign one of the top RPs on the market and also take one of those flyers on someone like Estevez. And there you go.

Seattle or Bust
Posts: 12133
Joined: Wed Mar 09, 2022 7:09 pm

Re: Off Season Plan Based on Current Rumors and Dipoto comments.

Post by Seattle or Bust » Tue Nov 17, 2026 11:02 pm

DavidGee24 wrote: ↑
Sat Nov 14, 2026 11:33 pm
Seattle or Bust wrote: ↑
Sat Nov 14, 2026 7:02 pm
I'm frankly tired about going around in circles with you.

1) You have often been wrong about the capital it's going to take to acquire players. The evidence is there in multiple threads that after the Mariners complete trades you're often dumbfounded. The Naylor, Geno, and Castillo trades are all evidence of this. How many times did I say Castillo could be traded and you mocked me? How many?

And your response was, "well it's not my fault the White Sox GM is such a moron." :roll: :roll: :roll:

2) You are often wrong about players and their eventual performance. That is why I'm highlighting what you said about Hancock and Arenado. So your evaluation in calling players "cooked" has to be in question because we have evidence of players turning it around after you've claimed they have no future in the sport.

3) Again, you never put forward any original ideas of your own. Make a plan numb nuts. You're sure good (not really...) at critiquing others but never put your own ass on the line. Well, it's because you're a narcissist... so the thought of being exposed for how little you actually know is terrifying.
You go in circles because you're a self-absorbed Libtard and can't handle dissenting opinions, much like you are in the Politics Forum.

And also very dishonest. I never said that Suarez, Naylor and Castillo couldn't be traded. Expressing surprise at the low cost is not the same thing. That's you changing the narrative, much like you do in the Politics Forum.

I'm rarely wrong about players' performance and we're not including Arenado. That's just you flat-out lying, much like you do in the Politics Forum.

Also, I was the one who called you the narcissist first and you're projecting...much like you do in the Politics Forum.

Want a plan? Okay, here's one. Make every effort to sign Sato. Make every effort to sign Suzuki and if doesn't happen, offer Kirby or Hancock for a good RH outfielder like Walker as you mentioned even though other players might need to be involved. Try and sign one of the top RPs on the market and also take one of those flyers on someone like Estevez. And there you go.
I can handle dissenting opinions just fine. I just want dissenting opinions with evidence. "Because I said so" isn't evidence. I always research opposing teams needs, I reference MLBTV for like value, and I look at trades that have been completed previously to compare to.

It's not projection at all lol. All you have to do is look at very clear traits of narcissism that you display all of the time.

1. You lack empathy in just about every way possible.
2. You can't admit ever when you're wrong.
3. You're constantly bragging about your stupid abilities in softball unprompted. It's not in defense of anything and nobody asks. "Wow... I could hit a softball 400 feet and Player X can't even get it out of the infield." "I could beat that throw out!!! and this guy is a Major Leaguer!?" Just shows delusional grandiosity.
4. You react with anger and rage to everything. All of your stupid posts over the years about dirt baths or how things don't count b/c "cheating."
5. You fake humility when called out.
6. You often need others to back you up your fragility. "Everyone here thinks..." Something you say all of the time.
7. You are constantly belittling others unprompted... it's trying to make them feel weak or small. Essentially you've been a weird bully ever since the Seattle Times days.

And I could go on and on...

DavidGee24
Posts: 11895
Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 6:24 pm
Location: Phillips Ranch, CA

Re: Off Season Plan Based on Current Rumors and Dipoto comments.

Post by DavidGee24 » Tue Nov 17, 2026 11:12 pm

Seattle or Bust wrote: ↑
Tue Nov 17, 2026 11:02 pm
1. You lack empathy in just about every way possible.
2. You can't admit ever when you're wrong.
3. You're constantly bragging about your stupid abilities in softball unprompted. It's not in defense of anything and nobody asks. "Wow... I could hit a softball 400 feet and Player X can't even get it out of the infield." "I could beat that throw out!!! and this guy is a Major Leaguer!?" Just shows delusional grandiosity.
4. You react with anger and rage to everything. All of your stupid posts over the years about dirt baths or how things don't count b/c "cheating."
5. You fake humility when called out.
6. You often need others to back you up your fragility. "Everyone here thinks..." Something you say all of the time.
7. You are constantly belittling others unprompted... it's trying to make them feel weak or small. Essentially you've been a weird bully ever since the Seattle Times days.
1. Projection/hypocrisy.
2. Not true. I've done so in the past, most recently it when I said that Teruaki Sato hit right-handed and then owned it.
3. LOL it's so funny that you take that seriously...although I probably could outrun J.P. Crawford.
4. See 1 and 3.
5. Not true.
6. And I'm not wrong. Odd coming from the guy who acts like he's fighting the world in these forums, cusses at others and recently posted "I HATE PEOPLE".
7. Projection/hypocrisy (points at Politics Forum).

Post Reply