According to fangraphs, among qualified shortstops the only guy that was paid more, but produced less was Javier Baez.
And that's at Crawfords $6M salary. Next year it jumps to $11M.
Aside from Baez, the only three guys that had lower production were each making $5M or less.
It's pretty hard to do worse than JP Crawford did in 2022. Paying him 8.5% of payroll (or about 1/12th of the overall budget) to do it is a little bit of a waste when his 2.0 fWAR is only 17th out of 21 qualified shortstops.
Shortstops get handed WAR for breathing.
https://www.fangraphs.com/leaders.aspx? ... 2022-12-31