D-train wrote: ↑Fri Oct 03, 2025 1:05 am
auroraave wrote: ↑Fri Oct 03, 2025 12:52 am
Captain 97 wrote: ↑Thu Oct 02, 2025 9:49 pm
They actually have quite a bit of playoff experience. Arozarena has been to the postseason 5 times and has some of the best post season numbers in the history of the game. Polanco has been in the post season 4 different times. Naylor has been 3 times and has 81 PA's in the post season. Geno has been 3 times. Garver has been to the playoffs 3 times and won a world series. Cal, Julio and JP were all there in 2022 for the M's. Raley Got a playoff AB for the Dodgers in the playoffs in his rookie season. Gilbert, Kirby, Castillo, Munoz and Brash all pitched in the post season in 2022. Castillo also pitched in a post season for Cincinnati.
The Mariners have played in a grand total of five playoff games since 2002 and were embarrassingly swept in their last series. If you feel this is a seasoned bunch that have been battle hardened and proven in the clutch - then we can just agree to disagree. Five games amassing a 2-3 record. Not exactly the Yankees. They had one relevant series this season and promptly swept the fading Astros - and then got curb stomped by the perennial playoff Dodgers - a potential WS match-up they could not handle. Not exactly awe inspiring, IMO.
So it has to be playoff experience with the M's and all other playoff experience with other teams doesn't count? I grant it isn't a lot but it isn't a little either.
It may not make any difference at all - that's totally possible. I just don't see this franchise as being post-season formidable - until they are. Experience on other teams doesn't matter to me - it's the Mariners - this group - this team - do they have the killer instinct, can they do it in the clutch. SO far I have seen nothing that says they do - but that also doesn't mean they don't - it all remains to be seen. That Dodger series was really sobering after kicking the Astros to the curb. At least this team is going all in - once they acquired Suarez and Naylor I knew this franchise was finally pushing all their chips on the table - and they (I think) have been the hottest team in baseball since. Once that happened I took 'em seriously.
I want them to win it all for all you forum guys that have stuck it out. I also worry it might result in many heart attacks so my wants are tempered.
