Jerry's Philosophy
Jerry's Philosophy
I don't post often (too much bickering for my taste) but something has bothered me for a while and I'd like to hear opinions.
Jerry's philosophy has clearly been to draft well, trade for need, and use free agency to fill gaps with supporting players.
While I like the draft-first strategy, relying so heavily on trades has kept us treading water (.540). By definition, a fair trade (over time) is a net-zero gain—trading from a position of strength to fill a hole is just robbing Peter to pay Paul. It undermines the entire value of drafting well if we trade those homegrown players away for more expensive veterans. Even more confounding is extending young players early rather than maximizing the years we can pay them near the league minimum and reduced arbitration rates. Anyone else wonder what Julio might have done if we didn't take away the $ incentive to improve?
The best teams take advantage of their minor league system by using the cost savings from team-controlled and arbitration years and reinvesting that money into impact free agents. Stop sending prospects to other teams for the privilege to pay market value on veterans...just sign veterans in FA.
Trades should be the last resort.
Drives me crazy.
Jerry's philosophy has clearly been to draft well, trade for need, and use free agency to fill gaps with supporting players.
While I like the draft-first strategy, relying so heavily on trades has kept us treading water (.540). By definition, a fair trade (over time) is a net-zero gain—trading from a position of strength to fill a hole is just robbing Peter to pay Paul. It undermines the entire value of drafting well if we trade those homegrown players away for more expensive veterans. Even more confounding is extending young players early rather than maximizing the years we can pay them near the league minimum and reduced arbitration rates. Anyone else wonder what Julio might have done if we didn't take away the $ incentive to improve?
The best teams take advantage of their minor league system by using the cost savings from team-controlled and arbitration years and reinvesting that money into impact free agents. Stop sending prospects to other teams for the privilege to pay market value on veterans...just sign veterans in FA.
Trades should be the last resort.
Drives me crazy.
- Sibelius Hindemith
- Posts: 16804
- Joined: Thu May 02, 2019 3:09 am
- Location: Seattle
Re: Jerry's Philosophy
Part of the problem is that they just can't develop hitting and so Jerry is forced to trade good prospects for players that have at least some track record of hitting at the major league level.
Re: Jerry's Philosophy
Do you think it's a lack of developing or identifying hitting talent? I'm unsure which I lean towards.
I think a more neutral ballpark would help tremendously.
I think a more neutral ballpark would help tremendously.
- Sibelius Hindemith
- Posts: 16804
- Joined: Thu May 02, 2019 3:09 am
- Location: Seattle
Re: Jerry's Philosophy
It just seems like the position player prospects that they trade are more successful relative to expectations than the ones they keep and develop (and promote to the majors).
Re: Jerry's Philosophy
Who are you thinking about?Sibelius Hindemith wrote: ↑Thu Nov 19, 2026 6:31 pmIt just seems like the position player prospects that they trade are more successful relative to expectations than the ones they keep and develop (and promote to the majors).
-
Captain 97
- Posts: 3996
- Joined: Mon May 06, 2019 9:23 pm
Re: Jerry's Philosophy
11 Years as GM and Cal Raleigh is the only position player that Jerry has drafted with a career WAR over 5. That includes the ones he has traded away.
-
DanielVogelbach
- Posts: 1537
- Joined: Sat Jun 08, 2019 7:43 pm
Re: Jerry's Philosophy
In the NFL, you draft a kid out of college and he's in the starting lineup immediately. In MLB you draft a player and they spend several years in the minor leagues developing and you have no idea if they will even become good players. So, the best course of action is to draft the best players available. If you end up heavy on pitching, you trade for hitting. If you end up with two stud catchers, you trade one. What other way is there to do it?
Re: Jerry's Philosophy
I get the idea of trading for a position of need from a position of strength, but that often leads to Ferrer and Donovan type trades. I doubt any of us would make either trade again. Needs should be addressed through internal promotions and FA whenever possible. We've now given up 3 top 5-15 prospects plus Miller to fill the position when there were multiple FA options last year.
To significantly and consistently improve, you need to add talent/WAR, not just distribute it differently.
To significantly and consistently improve, you need to add talent/WAR, not just distribute it differently.