Rate the position groups II

[D-train]

Honestly the only position group that we have that I would describe as any better than mediocre is the receivers.
QB 5
RB 6
WR 9
TE 5
OL 5
DL 6
LB 4
CB 6
S 4
ST 6

I don’t disagree a lot. I do like our RBs and curious to see how they are used. Last year it was so stupid to watch them take two backs with different skill sets and use them in ways that were entirely different than their skill set.

I am also a bit more optimistic on DL. I think our two big gets from last year benefit from a coaching change and that Murphy is a big add.

QB 5
RB 7
WR 8
TE 5
OL 5
DL 7
LB 4
CB 7
S 5
ST 7

Probably shouldn’t even have said “disagree”. I really only changed a few of your rankings slightly. I feel like this team could stumble and only win 7 games, but the new regime could also have them hitting in all cylinders quickly and we win 10 or 11!

6.0 Average = .6 x 17 = 10.2 win projection...spot on imo.

[douche]

To be clear... my ratings are based on where we're at right now, regardless of draft picks and additions, only because they're unproven. Until I see tangible improvements on the field, I can't be any more optimistic (or pessimistic) at the moment.

I struggled with this last season... on paper, SEA was pretty solid. On the field, not so much.

[Michael K.]

To be clear... my ratings are based on where we're at right now, regardless of draft picks and additions, only because they're unproven. Until I see tangible improvements on the field, I can't be any more optimistic (or pessimistic) at the moment.

I struggled with this last season... on paper, SEA was pretty solid. On the field, not so much.

In other words, your ratings are as of late December of last year. Not sure how that is very relevant. New coaching staff, new FA signings and an entire rookie class. If we are simply rating them off of what they did last year...Because, if you can't rate rookies, then you can't rate a FA that didn't play here. And, since we have an entirely new coaching staff? I guess you can't rate anyone?

[douche]

This is where it's confusing. The topic is, 'Rate the position groups II'. So that's what I did.

But I'm not projecting, I'm no good at it.

That said, the team made some nice additions via the draft.

Again, on paper they look solid. Hopefully that translates to the field.

[D-train]

To be clear... my ratings are based on where we're at right now, regardless of draft picks and additions, only because they're unproven. Until I see tangible improvements on the field, I can't be any more optimistic (or pessimistic) at the moment.

I struggled with this last season... on paper, SEA was pretty solid. On the field, not so much.

In other words, your ratings are as of late December of last year. Not sure how that is very relevant. New coaching staff, new FA signings and an entire rookie class. If we are simply rating them off of what they did last year...Because, if you can't rate rookies, then you can't rate a FA that didn't play here. And, since we have an entirely new coaching staff? I guess you can't rate anyone?

Based on 2023 I predict they will win 9 games this season.

[Sibelius Hindemith]

This is where it's confusing. The topic is, 'Rate the position groups II'. So that's what I did.

But I'm not projecting, I'm no good at it.

That said, the team made some nice additions via the draft.

Again, on paper they look solid. Hopefully that translates to the field.

As far as making projections, that was just something i threw in when i did this last year, but you are correct that how well they play will depend on more than just roster talent. I added that mainly to add some entertainment value to the thread lol.

[D-train]

It is pretty simple. Based on what you know about MM and the rest of the coaching staff, how the holdover players played for the Hawks last season and how new players played last season for their NFL or College teams you predict how effective they will be as a position group.

[D-train]

Murphy seems solid...For an Irish guy. Maoling has lowered the Bar. lol

[maoling]

Murphy seems solid...For an Irish guy. Maoling has lowered the Bar. lol

If I had feelings, they'd probably be hurt after that gratuitous pot shot. Besides, I'm not tall enough to raise the bar.


QB 6 I yam what i yam
RB 8 Cowabunga
WR 8 Cowabunga
TE 6 I yam what i yam
OL 6 I yam what i yam
DL 7 Hey hey hey
LB 6 I yam what i yam
CB 7 Hey hey hey
S 7 Hey hey hey
ST 7 Hey hey hey

Coug math gives me a 6.8 avg.

That's all I got. Except Darren can blow me.

[D-train]

Murphy seems solid...For an Irish guy. Maoling has lowered the Bar. lol

If I had feelings, they'd probably be hurt after that gratuitous pot shot. Besides, I'm not tall enough to raise the bar.


QB 6 I yam what i yam
RB 8 Cowabunga
WR 8 Cowabunga
TE 6 I yam what i yam
OL 6 I yam what i yam
DL 7 Hey hey hey
LB 6 I yam what i yam
CB 7 Hey hey hey
S 7 Hey hey hey
ST 7 Hey hey hey

Coug math gives me a 6.8 avg.

That's all I got. Except Darren can blow me.