The sample sizes for Robles and Raley are a bit small and their numbers are likely anomalous, but it seems to me that there is a batting profile that is more likely to succeed at T-Mobile, and players with low discipline and long swings (regardless of power) don't fit it.Seattle or Bust wrote: ↑Thu Jan 09, 2025 5:24 pmLuke Raley: .901 OPS at home / .666 OPS away
Victor Robles: .983 OPS at home / .698 OPS away
Cal Raleigh: .665 OPS at home / .823 OPS away ... 2023: .730 OPS at home / .794 OPS away ... 2022: .600 OPS at home /.961 OPS away
Julio Rodriguez: .655 OPS at home / .805 OPS away ... 2023: .785 OPS at home/ .850 OPS away ... 2022: .892 OPS at home /.820 OPS away
JP Crawford: .480 OPS at home / .762 OPS away ... 2023: .842 OPS at home/ .793 OPS away
Ty France: 2023: .756 OPS at home / .652 away ... 2022: .784 OPS at home / .765 OPS away
Can anyone explain the pure insanity of these numbers?
I posted this the other day but nobody responded to it...
The thing that gets me is the utter polarity... people either hit at an MVP level in this stadium or crater to DFA territory.
T Mobile, a hitters worst nightmare
- Sibelius Hindemith
- Posts: 13153
- Joined: Thu May 02, 2019 3:09 am
- Location: Seattle
Re: T Mobile, a hitters worst nightmare
-
- Posts: 12313
- Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 5:27 am
Re: T Mobile, a hitters worst nightmare
There's been an evolution in pitching the last 5-10 years towards greater velocity and more movement, and a new pitch, the horizontal slider, or sweeper, has become more popular and more refined. And with Statcast installed in every park, pitching staffs now have a supercharged ability to diagnose the strengths and weaknesses of individual hitters.
It would be interesting to see how the offensive numbers in TMO park have fared during this period. In other words, is it just the park that we're dealing with right now or is it the unique synergy of the league's worst hitting environment COMBINED WITH this league wide advancement in pitching? I think, probably, this is at least a partial explanation of what happened with Julio last year. The league systematically exploited his weaknesses with breaking pitches and offspeed, and this was simply way more effective at home in this horrific hitting environment.
It would be interesting to see how the offensive numbers in TMO park have fared during this period. In other words, is it just the park that we're dealing with right now or is it the unique synergy of the league's worst hitting environment COMBINED WITH this league wide advancement in pitching? I think, probably, this is at least a partial explanation of what happened with Julio last year. The league systematically exploited his weaknesses with breaking pitches and offspeed, and this was simply way more effective at home in this horrific hitting environment.
Re: T Mobile, a hitters worst nightmare
I am not sure, but the power part might be off, (Safeco---> tmobile transition has given the profile of a near neutral park for home run numbers.) The M's home park is at or near worst in terms of singles, doubles, triples, walks & highest in K%. Should we target home run hitting hitters? I don't like the inconsistency of the boom or boost philosophy, but if that is the blue-print of our home stadium's bias? What can you do?Sibelius Hindemith wrote: ↑Thu Jan 09, 2025 5:46 pmThe sample sizes for Robles and Raley are a bit small and their numbers are likely anomalous, but it seems to me that there is a batting profile that is more likely to succeed at T-Mobile, and players with low discipline and long swings (regardless of power) don't fit it.Seattle or Bust wrote: ↑Thu Jan 09, 2025 5:24 pmLuke Raley: .901 OPS at home / .666 OPS away
Victor Robles: .983 OPS at home / .698 OPS away
Cal Raleigh: .665 OPS at home / .823 OPS away ... 2023: .730 OPS at home / .794 OPS away ... 2022: .600 OPS at home /.961 OPS away
Julio Rodriguez: .655 OPS at home / .805 OPS away ... 2023: .785 OPS at home/ .850 OPS away ... 2022: .892 OPS at home /.820 OPS away
JP Crawford: .480 OPS at home / .762 OPS away ... 2023: .842 OPS at home/ .793 OPS away
Ty France: 2023: .756 OPS at home / .652 away ... 2022: .784 OPS at home / .765 OPS away
Can anyone explain the pure insanity of these numbers?
I posted this the other day but nobody responded to it...
The thing that gets me is the utter polarity... people either hit at an MVP level in this stadium or crater to DFA territory.
Re: T Mobile, a hitters worst nightmare
The question that needs to be asked is....has it always been this way? Or is this because of the current 3 scenario hitting style of most everyone: walk, strikeout, or homerun?Pharmabro wrote: ↑Fri Jan 10, 2025 8:26 amI am not sure, but the power part might be off, (Safeco---> tmobile transition has given the profile of a near neutral park for home run numbers.) The M's home park is at or near worst in terms of singles, doubles, triples, walks & highest in K%. Should we target home run hitting hitters? I don't like the inconsistency of the boom or boost philosophy, but if that is the blue-print of our home stadium's bias? What can you do?Sibelius Hindemith wrote: ↑Thu Jan 09, 2025 5:46 pmThe sample sizes for Robles and Raley are a bit small and their numbers are likely anomalous, but it seems to me that there is a batting profile that is more likely to succeed at T-Mobile, and players with low discipline and long swings (regardless of power) don't fit it.Seattle or Bust wrote: ↑Thu Jan 09, 2025 5:24 pmLuke Raley: .901 OPS at home / .666 OPS away
Victor Robles: .983 OPS at home / .698 OPS away
Cal Raleigh: .665 OPS at home / .823 OPS away ... 2023: .730 OPS at home / .794 OPS away ... 2022: .600 OPS at home /.961 OPS away
Julio Rodriguez: .655 OPS at home / .805 OPS away ... 2023: .785 OPS at home/ .850 OPS away ... 2022: .892 OPS at home /.820 OPS away
JP Crawford: .480 OPS at home / .762 OPS away ... 2023: .842 OPS at home/ .793 OPS away
Ty France: 2023: .756 OPS at home / .652 away ... 2022: .784 OPS at home / .765 OPS away
Can anyone explain the pure insanity of these numbers?
I posted this the other day but nobody responded to it...
The thing that gets me is the utter polarity... people either hit at an MVP level in this stadium or crater to DFA territory.
Re: T Mobile, a hitters worst nightmare
I’m guessing there’s a simple answer to this but if the Kingdom was a hitter’s park then playing with the roof closed should help at T Mobile
-
- Posts: 3102
- Joined: Mon May 06, 2019 9:23 pm
Re: T Mobile, a hitters worst nightmare
No it wouldn't. The Kingdome was completely enclosed and climate controlled. The T-mobile roof is nothing but a giant carport and doesn't modify temperature, air density and humidity levels.
- Donn Beach
- Posts: 15849
- Joined: Thu May 02, 2019 1:06 am
Re: T Mobile, a hitters worst nightmare
Closing the roof doesn't really enclose TMobile. I don't see a relationship to the King dome. The King dome had some pretty short dimensions, artificial turf. I'm going to guess a better batting eye. And a controlled environment. Closing the roof of TMobile doesn't accomplish any of that. Though it could help eliminate sun glare. That's kinda of a typical Seattle thing isn't it. What's that thing in the sky? OMG we can't hit it's too bright!
- Donn Beach
- Posts: 15849
- Joined: Thu May 02, 2019 1:06 am
Re: T Mobile, a hitters worst nightmare
For those that might not be familiar with what I was getting at
So we tear down the kingdome and build an outdoor stadium with a roof we can close at great expense when it rains but wait a minute, we need to close it as well when the sun is out. Hmmm what am I missing, as dtrain would say, you couldn't make this stuff up
https://archive.seattletimes.com/archiv ... ng-problem"It's scary; it really is scary," said Boone, who said he did not see the fastball from the Minnesota Twins' Kyle Lohse on Saturday. "You cannot see the ball on a lot of pitches. We can't see half the pitches in our own park half the time. It's especially bad later in the 3 o'clock (3:35) starts and early in the 6 o'clock games."
This is not the first time a Mariner has broached this issue. There have been a few comments in public, but none as frank as Boone's.
In most instances, players have expressed their strongest feelings in private discussions with club officials.
In 1999, in what many insiders believe was one factor in his decision to leave, Ken Griffey Jr. called then General Manager Woody Woodward during a game and demanded that the roof be closed. Woodward's response reportedly was that the outfielder should never call him during a game again.
And in 2000, Alex Rodriguez's final season with the Mariners, the shortstop reportedly got into heated arguments with team president Chuck Armstrong over the issue of closing the roof on sunny days.
So we tear down the kingdome and build an outdoor stadium with a roof we can close at great expense when it rains but wait a minute, we need to close it as well when the sun is out. Hmmm what am I missing, as dtrain would say, you couldn't make this stuff up
Re: T Mobile, a hitters worst nightmare
Donn Beach wrote: ↑Fri Jan 10, 2025 5:13 pmFor those that might not be familiar with what I was getting at
https://archive.seattletimes.com/archiv ... ng-problem"It's scary; it really is scary," said Boone, who said he did not see the fastball from the Minnesota Twins' Kyle Lohse on Saturday. "You cannot see the ball on a lot of pitches. We can't see half the pitches in our own park half the time. It's especially bad later in the 3 o'clock (3:35) starts and early in the 6 o'clock games."
This is not the first time a Mariner has broached this issue. There have been a few comments in public, but none as frank as Boone's.
In most instances, players have expressed their strongest feelings in private discussions with club officials.
In 1999, in what many insiders believe was one factor in his decision to leave, Ken Griffey Jr. called then General Manager Woody Woodward during a game and demanded that the roof be closed. Woodward's response reportedly was that the outfielder should never call him during a game again.
And in 2000, Alex Rodriguez's final season with the Mariners, the shortstop reportedly got into heated arguments with team president Chuck Armstrong over the issue of closing the roof on sunny days.
So we tear down the kingdome and build an outdoor stadium with a roof we can close at great expense when it rains but wait a minute, we need to close it as well when the sun is out. Hmmm what am I missing, as dtrain would say, you couldn't make this stuff up
dt