It's so insanely idiotic and statistically indefensible that he'll probably go 4 for 4 with 2 homeruns.
Or maybe something like this happened:
Dan: Do I really have to start Refsnyder today?
Jerry: Absolutely! He's great vs left-handers in his career and that's why we invested $6 million.
Dan: Whatever you say boss
Then Dan thinks to himself... Jerry, since you love Refsnyder so much, I'll bat him cleanup.