Top 50 Mariners of all time

[DavidGee24]

30. Logan Gilbert
29. Floyd Bannister
28. Harold Reynolds
27. Raul Ibanez
26. Phil Bradley
25. Erik Hanson
24. MItch Haniger
23. Hisashi Iwakuma
22. Mike Moore
21. J.P. Crawford

On what planet is Moore #22? In four of his seven seasons with the Mariners he SUCKED. Iwakuma and Hanson were way better, and Gilbert is way better. WTF

JP? Fuck that.

He is our #2 shortstop of all time, but even #31 overall is pushing it.

[Michael K.]

30. Logan Gilbert
29. Floyd Bannister
28. Harold Reynolds
27. Raul Ibanez
26. Phil Bradley
25. Erik Hanson
24. MItch Haniger
23. Hisashi Iwakuma
22. Mike Moore
21. J.P. Crawford

On what planet is Moore #22? In four of his seven seasons with the Mariners he SUCKED. Iwakuma and Hanson were way better, and Gilbert is way better. WTF

JP? Fuck that.

He is our #2 shortstop of all time, but even #31 overall is pushing it.

Seriously? Omar and A Rod are both 100 times better. I'd take fucking Felix Fermin. What about the dude that hit the inside the park finger to get us in in 95? J fucking P? What a sad franchise I grew up with is that fucking noodle swinging mother fucker is the second best SS of all time?

What did we do to deserve this type of rudderless ship bullshit?

[DavidGee24]

JP? Fuck that.

He is our #2 shortstop of all time, but even #31 overall is pushing it.

Seriously? Omar and A Rod are both 100 times better. I'd take fucking Felix Fermin. What about the dude that hit the inside the park finger to get us in in 95? J fucking P? What a sad franchise I grew up with is that fucking noodle swinging mother fucker is the second best SS of all time?

What did we do to deserve this type of rudderless ship bullshit?

Fermin was only a Mariner for two seasons and the second one was a disaster. Luis Sojo was a Mariner for three seasons and in two of them he hit well but wasn't really a good fielder.

Vizquel was indeed better than JP...in an Indian uniform. His five years with us he was mostly good field/no hit. His bat didn't come around until after he left. I think him being #3 behind JP is fair.

[Michael K.]

I disagree. But I also can't stand this team, so there is that. Never liked JP. Thought they could have had better options many times but stuck with his weak ass.

[DavidGee24]

10. Robinson Cano
9. Julio Rodriguez
8. Jamie Moyer
7. Kyle Seager
6. Felix Hernandez
5. Randy Johnson
4. Alex Rodriguez
3. Ichiro
2. Edgar Martinez
1. Junior

Here's a good question for everyone: if our top five had played their entire careers for the Mariners, who would be #1? I think it would be Randy, the numbers he would have put up after the ballpark move would have been Koufaxish.

[Michael K.]

Sounds like Seager told them thanks but no thanks. Dipoto is such a scum bag.

[DavidGee24]

Sounds like Seager told them thanks but no thanks. Dipoto is such a scum bag.

Yeah, he was saying that he was coaching his son in a big tournament but apparently the tournament ended a few days ago. I wonder what happened.

[D-train]

JP? Fuck that.

He is our #2 shortstop of all time, but even #31 overall is pushing it.

Seriously? Omar and A Rod are both 100 times better. I'd take fucking Felix Fermin. What about the dude that hit the inside the park finger to get us in in 95? J fucking P? What a sad franchise I grew up with is that fucking noodle swinging mother fucker is the second best SS of all time?

What did we do to deserve this type of rudderless ship bullshit?

You know I am not a JP fan but

Fermin put up -1.3 WAR for us in two seasons. -1.7 in 1995
Luis Sojo put up 2.6 WAR for us in 2 seasons
Omar put up 10.3 WAR
JP has put up 21.5 WAR
Arod put up 38.1 WAR and will be ranked top 5, prob 5th after Jr. Edgar Randy and Ichiro.

[D-train]

Sounds like Seager told them thanks but no thanks. Dipoto is such a scum bag.

[D-train]

Jim Moore's bottom 50. Have to subscribe for the bottom 10. He did a good job with 50-11

https://jimmoorethego2guy.substack.com/ ... -franchise