2026-27 Hot Stove Thread
Re: 2026-27 Hot Stove Thread
One flaw in my offseason plan is its reliance on Baseball Trade Values, which likely vastly undervalues acquired relievers Tyler Wells and Brent Headrick. In similar annual values, BTV assigns one year of Wells a surplus value of $1.6 million and five years of Headrick a surplus value of $8.1 million.
Check out the Baseball Savant pages for Wells and Headrick:
Wells: https://baseballsavant.mlb.com/savant-p ... tching-mlb
Headrick: https://baseballsavant.mlb.com/savant-p ... tching-mlb
Check out the Baseball Savant pages for Wells and Headrick:
Wells: https://baseballsavant.mlb.com/savant-p ... tching-mlb
Headrick: https://baseballsavant.mlb.com/savant-p ... tching-mlb
Re: 2026-27 Hot Stove Thread
I wouldn't re-sign Gilbert at this point. I think you either trade him or you plan on letting him walk at the end of the year. He's a good pitcher, but he isn't the franchise.
-
HawkandMariner88
- Posts: 1632
- Joined: Sat May 04, 2019 10:33 pm
Re: 2026-27 Hot Stove Thread
Shit trade both Gilbert & Kirby at this point. I wouldn't be paying big bucks for any of these guys.
-
DavidGee24
- Posts: 11850
- Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 6:24 pm
- Location: Phillips Ranch, CA
Re: 2026-27 Hot Stove Thread
Agreed. He's never realized his ace potential because he just can't shake the penchant for dominating but then giving up the big game-losing hit(s). There's never been as crazy a WHIP/ERA imbalance in MLB history as there has been with Gilbert. He's just got that loser intangible, which of course we saw in the ALCS in 2025 when he pitched like shit.
Re: 2026-27 Hot Stove Thread
I just think he's a number 3 starter, which is valuable, but I don't know why you would pay market rate for that on a long term deal with the player going into his age 30 season, and with a lot of mileage on that arm. It just seems kind of crazy when the one thing you do well as an organization is drafting and developing young starting pitchers.DavidGee24 wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 4:57 amAgreed. He's never realized his ace potential because he just can't shake the penchant for dominating but then giving up the big game-losing hit(s). There's never been as crazy a WHIP/ERA imbalance in MLB history as there has been with Gilbert. He's just got that loser intangible, which of course we saw in the ALCS in 2025 when he pitched like shit.
-
Captain 97
- Posts: 3978
- Joined: Mon May 06, 2019 9:23 pm
Re: 2026-27 Hot Stove Thread
This is one of the most ridiculous takes I have ever seen on this forum. I agree he's not a top of the line Ace but a #3?GL_Storm wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 7:08 amI just think he's a number 3 starter, which is valuable, but I don't know why you would pay market rate for that on a long term deal with the player going into his age 30 season, and with a lot of mileage on that arm. It just seems kind of crazy when the one thing you do well as an organization is drafting and developing young starting pitchers.DavidGee24 wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 4:57 amAgreed. He's never realized his ace potential because he just can't shake the penchant for dominating but then giving up the big game-losing hit(s). There's never been as crazy a WHIP/ERA imbalance in MLB history as there has been with Gilbert. He's just got that loser intangible, which of course we saw in the ALCS in 2025 when he pitched like shit.
A number 3 implies that the average team has 2 starting pitchers better than him. The dude is top 30 in literally every significant pitching category. 27th in WAR 23rd in ERA, 10th in WHIP, 14th in K/9, 20th in Wins, 8th in Innings and 28th in Quality Starts. He would be the ace on a significant number of teams and at least the number 2 or better on the vast majority of teams.
I am not sure that I want to give him the money that its going to take to retain him either, but casually calling the guy a #3 is wild.
Re: 2026-27 Hot Stove Thread
I stand by the statement. I don't agree that saying so means the average team has two starters better than him. Ultimately there's a level of subjectivity when we assign these labels to starting pitchers.Captain 97 wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 4:15 pmThis is one of the most ridiculous takes I have ever seen on this forum. I agree he's not a top of the line Ace but a #3?GL_Storm wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 7:08 amI just think he's a number 3 starter, which is valuable, but I don't know why you would pay market rate for that on a long term deal with the player going into his age 30 season, and with a lot of mileage on that arm. It just seems kind of crazy when the one thing you do well as an organization is drafting and developing young starting pitchers.DavidGee24 wrote: ↑Mon Nov 16, 2026 4:57 am
Agreed. He's never realized his ace potential because he just can't shake the penchant for dominating but then giving up the big game-losing hit(s). There's never been as crazy a WHIP/ERA imbalance in MLB history as there has been with Gilbert. He's just got that loser intangible, which of course we saw in the ALCS in 2025 when he pitched like shit.
A number 3 implies that the average team has 2 starting pitchers better than him. The dude is top 30 in literally every significant pitching category. 27th in WAR 23rd in ERA, 10th in WHIP, 14th in K/9, 20th in Wins, 8th in Innings and 28th in Quality Starts. He would be the ace on a significant number of teams and at least the number 2 or better on the vast majority of teams.
I am not sure that I want to give him the money that its going to take to retain him either, but casually calling the guy a #3 is wild.
Maybe a tier list concept would make more sense though. Ultimately, I see Logan Gilbert as a workhorse type pitcher with good stuff that occasionally dominates a game. Maybe some people would describe that as a #2 starter, which I suppose is fine. But my eye test judgement after watching him for five years is that he's more in the mid-rotation category. He's closer to a 50 than a 55.
Re: 2026-27 Hot Stove Thread
Jerry had better get in the stick and get a quality reliever as he has a lot of competition. If he dicks around and ends up settling for mediocre then we will end up running in place again
-
Captain 97
- Posts: 3978
- Joined: Mon May 06, 2019 9:23 pm
Re: 2026-27 Hot Stove Thread
Awe yes the old eye test.
By definition there at least 60 #1 and #2 Starters in the league. By any objective measurement there are not anywhere close to 60 starting pitchers better than Gilbert. There aren't even 30.
Re: 2026-27 Hot Stove Thread
I agree with Captain but it is all moot. Dude will be an FA in less than a year and will get paid and it won't be by us.
dt