Lots to love about his defense, and he could get away with not hitting for power except that he hits for a moderate average and doesn't really get on base beyond that. Career OBP of .322. Hey, he could surprise us, he's still reasonably young, but his track record says he probably won't and we really need hitters.
Blockbuster per Passan!
-
DavidGee24
- Posts: 11888
- Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 6:24 pm
- Location: Phillips Ranch, CA
Re: Blockbuster per Passan!
-
DavidGee24
- Posts: 11888
- Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 6:24 pm
- Location: Phillips Ranch, CA
Re: Blockbuster per Passan!
Oh okay, because some random person like the random people on Darren's and BPJ's social media feeds said. Well gosh, that's totally different! I mean, 344 plate appearances in 2026, it unequivocably stands to reason that out of every single pitch (well over 1,000) thrown to him, every single strike was on the outer half of the plate and none of them were either right down the middle or on the inside half of the plate, because pitchers never make mistakes and Garcia never got anything good to hit. Thanks to you and the random Internet person so much for setting us straight on that.Seattle or Bust wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 6:57 amAre you having psychosis?
I have addressed what Darren said. I said it would be expected that he hits 10-20 homers and that his power dip was likely due to a wrist injury suffered from a hit by pitch in April and the pain he tried to play through.
"Garcia noted that the pain flared up specifically on swings toward the outer half of the plate, where pitchers targeted him to exploit the injury. He described how the 15-second pitch clock left no time to recover from the sharp pain between swings, making it difficult to perform."
"While clean contact in the cage caused no issues, fouled balls or jammed swings aggravated the left-hand lumbrical muscle strain. Garcia remarked on the uncertainty of the injury, noting that a return to play could trigger pain on the very first swing."
The Liberal playbook? Lay off the roids chud... the roid rage is ripping through your last remaining brain cells... Seek help. Genuinely.
As for roids, I've never touched them nor have I ever even so much as touched a joint. On the other hand, I'd imagine that you have a rubber band hooked at one end around the handle of your medicine cabinet and the other end hooked around a nail in the wall to keep your pills from falling out.
-
Seattle or Bust
- Posts: 12133
- Joined: Wed Mar 09, 2022 7:09 pm
Re: Blockbuster per Passan!
Some random person?DavidGee24 wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 5:19 pmOh okay, because some random person like the random people on Darren's and BPJ's social media feeds said. Well gosh, that's totally different! I mean, 344 plate appearances in 2026, it unequivocably stands to reason that out of every single pitch (well over 1,000) thrown to him, every single strike was on the outer half of the plate and none of them were either right down the middle or on the inside half of the plate, because pitchers never make mistakes and Garcia never got anything good to hit. Thanks to you and the random Internet person so much for setting us straight on that.Seattle or Bust wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 6:57 amAre you having psychosis?
I have addressed what Darren said. I said it would be expected that he hits 10-20 homers and that his power dip was likely due to a wrist injury suffered from a hit by pitch in April and the pain he tried to play through.
"Garcia noted that the pain flared up specifically on swings toward the outer half of the plate, where pitchers targeted him to exploit the injury. He described how the 15-second pitch clock left no time to recover from the sharp pain between swings, making it difficult to perform."
"While clean contact in the cage caused no issues, fouled balls or jammed swings aggravated the left-hand lumbrical muscle strain. Garcia remarked on the uncertainty of the injury, noting that a return to play could trigger pain on the very first swing."
The Liberal playbook? Lay off the roids chud... the roid rage is ripping through your last remaining brain cells... Seek help. Genuinely.
As for roids, I've never touched them nor have I ever even so much as touched a joint. On the other hand, I'd imagine that you have a rubber band hooked at one end around the handle of your medicine cabinet and the other end hooked around a nail in the wall to keep your pills from falling out.
They are literally quoting what Garcia said in interviews about his wrist and how the injury impacted his bat...
"Garcia noted" ... "Garcia remarked" ...
It is HIS explanation for why his power and bat suffered post getting hit on the wrist.
What in the fuck is wrong with you?
Re: Blockbuster per Passan!
I have nothing fresh to add to the news of the blockbuster trade. I have even less to add to the fracas between SoB and DavidGee. For the former, I think on balance it is a great trade - locks down the hot corner with a guy who will undoubtedly surge again to All Star, Gold Glove levels. And we got rid of Miller who - while being a serviceable enough pitcher - was showing signs of decline over the past few seasons, and had that persistent bone spur in his throwing arm. Of the pitching staff we had to play with, he is the one I would be happiest to see go.
My best guess is that Garcia regains his form in Seattle - defensively he'll be a stud, and offensively my hope is he hits well enough to be at least league which will be a net gain for us, in sum. For the Royals, I think pessimistically they inherited a ticking time bomb. Miller's bone spurs will plague him and effect his pitching, and possibly require season ending surgery.
This may come down to how well the other players involved with the trade pan out. The Mariners do have an ability to polish turds in the bullpen.
Here's one other thought on how they should follow up. I think they pursue Suzuki - pay whatever it takes. That anchors our outfield. But I think they should non-tender Raley. That experiment has run its course. In all likelihood, Jake Burger will be non-tendered by the Rangers. Defensively, he's a liability, but the guy has right handed power. Sign him to a 1 year deal as our primary DH and sit back and watch the Burger Bombs. Boom.
Follow me on this:
If the Mariners non-tender Luke Raley to shed his $3.1 million arbitration projection and sign a non-tendered Jake Burger on a one-year, incentive-friendly deal around $4 million to $5 million, Seattle upgrades its Designated Hitter spot for a net payroll bump of roughly $1 million to $2 million.
While both hitters posted a .723 OPS in 2026, Burger is a much better fit for a primary DH role because he brings everyday right-handed power (hitting 28 home runs with 90 RBI across 556 at-bats compared to Raley's 15 home runs and 39 RBI in 262 at-bats) and balances a lineup that leans heavily left-handed.
Starting Lineup
Dominic Canzone (LF) – L
Julio Rodríguez (CF) – R
Seiya Suzuki (RF) – R
Cal Raleigh (C) – S
Josh Naylor (1B) – L
Jake Burger (DH) – R
Maikel Garcia (3B) – R
Cole Young (2B) – L
Colt Emerson (SS) – L
Bench
Brendan Donovan (UTL/INF/OF) – L
Lazaro Montes (OF/DH) – L
Jhonny Pereda (C) – R
Brock Rodden (INF) – S
My best guess is that Garcia regains his form in Seattle - defensively he'll be a stud, and offensively my hope is he hits well enough to be at least league which will be a net gain for us, in sum. For the Royals, I think pessimistically they inherited a ticking time bomb. Miller's bone spurs will plague him and effect his pitching, and possibly require season ending surgery.
This may come down to how well the other players involved with the trade pan out. The Mariners do have an ability to polish turds in the bullpen.
Here's one other thought on how they should follow up. I think they pursue Suzuki - pay whatever it takes. That anchors our outfield. But I think they should non-tender Raley. That experiment has run its course. In all likelihood, Jake Burger will be non-tendered by the Rangers. Defensively, he's a liability, but the guy has right handed power. Sign him to a 1 year deal as our primary DH and sit back and watch the Burger Bombs. Boom.
Follow me on this:
If the Mariners non-tender Luke Raley to shed his $3.1 million arbitration projection and sign a non-tendered Jake Burger on a one-year, incentive-friendly deal around $4 million to $5 million, Seattle upgrades its Designated Hitter spot for a net payroll bump of roughly $1 million to $2 million.
While both hitters posted a .723 OPS in 2026, Burger is a much better fit for a primary DH role because he brings everyday right-handed power (hitting 28 home runs with 90 RBI across 556 at-bats compared to Raley's 15 home runs and 39 RBI in 262 at-bats) and balances a lineup that leans heavily left-handed.
Starting Lineup
Dominic Canzone (LF) – L
Julio Rodríguez (CF) – R
Seiya Suzuki (RF) – R
Cal Raleigh (C) – S
Josh Naylor (1B) – L
Jake Burger (DH) – R
Maikel Garcia (3B) – R
Cole Young (2B) – L
Colt Emerson (SS) – L
Bench
Brendan Donovan (UTL/INF/OF) – L
Lazaro Montes (OF/DH) – L
Jhonny Pereda (C) – R
Brock Rodden (INF) – S
-
DavidGee24
- Posts: 11888
- Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 6:24 pm
- Location: Phillips Ranch, CA
Re: Blockbuster per Passan!
Those aren't literal quotes, that's an attempt at paraphrasing. What is wrong with WHO again?Seattle or Bust wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 5:45 pmSome random person?
They are literally quoting what Garcia said in interviews about his wrist and how the injury impacted his bat...
"Garcia noted" ... "Garcia remarked" ...
It is HIS explanation for why his power and bat suffered post getting hit on the wrist.
What in the fuck is wrong with you?
I found this from a Kansas City Star interview at the end of last season. Apparently the hand injury affected him in the early part of the season, he missed two months, then came back with his hand seemingly healed but then he immediately hurt his hamstring and ended up missing more time. None of us caught this and hopefully it explains a lot as to why he didn't hit. There might have been more quotes but I would have had to subscribe to their paper to see it.
FROM THE ARTICLE: This season, Garcia has dealt with multiple injuries that zapped his production and caused him to be missing in action. A muscle strain in his left hand cost him nearly two months. And days later, Garcia was back on the injured list with a Grade 1 left hamstring strain. In total, Garcia missed 67 games due to injuries. “I’ve been working hard all my rehab for my hand and my hamstring,” Garcia said, “and, you know, be able to play games in the big leagues. Like, last year, I was healthy all year and I think my new weight in my body this year was bigger. My body didn’t get used to it. So I think it’s just get to my normal weight and be able to play."
-
Seattle or Bust
- Posts: 12133
- Joined: Wed Mar 09, 2022 7:09 pm
Re: Blockbuster per Passan!
Yes... journalists use quotes to support a general narrative to what Garcia himself was attributing to the drop in production.DavidGee24 wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 6:11 pmThose aren't literal quotes, that's an attempt at paraphrasing. What is wrong with WHO again?Seattle or Bust wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 5:45 pmSome random person?
They are literally quoting what Garcia said in interviews about his wrist and how the injury impacted his bat...
"Garcia noted" ... "Garcia remarked" ...
It is HIS explanation for why his power and bat suffered post getting hit on the wrist.
What in the fuck is wrong with you?
I found this from a Kansas City Star interview at the end of last season. Apparently the hand injury affected him in the early part of the season, he missed two months, then came back with his hand seemingly healed but then he immediately hurt his hamstring and ended up missing more time. None of us caught this and hopefully it explains a lot as to why he didn't hit. There might have been more quotes but I would have had to subscribe to their paper to see it.
FROM THE ARTICLE: This season, Garcia has dealt with multiple injuries that zapped his production and caused him to be missing in action. A muscle strain in his left hand cost him nearly two months. And days later, Garcia was back on the injured list with a Grade 1 left hamstring strain. In total, Garcia missed 67 games due to injuries. “I’ve been working hard all my rehab for my hand and my hamstring,” Garcia said, “and, you know, be able to play games in the big leagues. Like, last year, I was healthy all year and I think my new weight in my body this year was bigger. My body didn’t get used to it. So I think it’s just get to my normal weight and be able to play."
"Garcia has dealt with multiple injuries that zapped his production and caused him to be missing in action."
THIS being the general narrative.
You're a fucking moron. Truly.
-
DavidGee24
- Posts: 11888
- Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 6:24 pm
- Location: Phillips Ranch, CA
Re: Blockbuster per Passan!
Very well said, Maple. If we sign Suzuki in addition to acquiring Garcia, with bounceback seasons from Raleigh and Naylor we look a lot better on paper. I'd be a bit wary of Burger, although if we end up having to settle on him it's better than what we usually settle on.Big_Maple wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 6:01 pmMy best guess is that Garcia regains his form in Seattle - defensively he'll be a stud, and offensively my hope is he hits well enough to be at least league which will be a net gain for us, in sum. For the Royals, I think pessimistically they inherited a ticking time bomb. Miller's bone spurs will plague him and effect his pitching, and possibly require season ending surgery.
This may come down to how well the other players involved with the trade pan out. The Mariners do have an ability to polish turds in the bullpen.
Here's one other thought on how they should follow up. I think they pursue Suzuki - pay whatever it takes. That anchors our outfield. But I think they should non-tender Raley. That experiment has run its course. In all likelihood, Jake Burger will be non-tendered by the Rangers. Defensively, he's a liability, but the guy has right handed power. Sign him to a 1 year deal as our primary DH and sit back and watch the Burger Bombs. Boom.
Re: Blockbuster per Passan!
I am optimistic, actually. I was down on their choice of manager for a while, but I think the clean sweep in the dugout might refresh everything. Maybe there is leadership potential I don't see, and the new coaching staff can get our reliable bats, swinging again. If they can help Raleigh, Julio, and Naylor regain their form, then we could add another 5-7 wins to last year's record. Add Suzuki's and Garcia's defense, and that saves us another 3 or 4 games. If they sign Burger, and he hits Burger Bombs, our DH could net us another 2-3 games. The arrival and Anderson and Sloan (and the loss of Castillo and Miller) could be another few games. Suddenly, the confluence of roster upgrades nets us 10-15 more wins than last season (conservatively). Hello, AL West pennant.DavidGee24 wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 6:24 pm
Very well said, Maple. If we sign Suzuki in addition to acquiring Garcia, with bounceback seasons from Raleigh and Naylor we look a lot better on paper. I'd be a bit wary of Burger, although if we end up having to settle on him it's better than what we usually settle on.
How much better we really get also depends on the bullpen. Management can't half-ass this - they need to g out and sign 2, maybe 3 dominant to elite arms. I know this is not their style, but they need to bolster the bullpen, especially the back end.
This could be a World Series roster with just a few more big moves ("big" by our standards. Pedestrian by Dodgers or Mets standards).
-
DavidGee24
- Posts: 11888
- Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 6:24 pm
- Location: Phillips Ranch, CA
Re: Blockbuster per Passan!
So you go from this:

To this (after I correctly pointed out that none of us noticed his weight and hamstring issues):Seattle or Bust wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 6:57 am"Garcia noted that the pain flared up specifically on swings toward the outer half of the plate, where pitchers targeted him to exploit the injury. He described how the 15-second pitch clock left no time to recover from the sharp pain between swings, making it difficult to perform."
"While clean contact in the cage caused no issues, fouled balls or jammed swings aggravated the left-hand lumbrical (hand) muscle strain. Garcia remarked on the uncertainty of the injury, noting that a return to play could trigger pain on the very first swing."
And cuss and name-call. Okee-dokee.Seattle or Bust wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 6:22 pm"Garcia has dealt with multiple injuries that zapped his production and caused him to be missing in action."
-
DavidGee24
- Posts: 11888
- Joined: Wed May 01, 2019 6:24 pm
- Location: Phillips Ranch, CA
Re: Blockbuster per Passan!
I'm optimistic too, although we do need to make a big splash in the bullpen as well. If we do that, my crazy ass will probably again pick the most wins in the Season Win Prediction Contest.Big_Maple wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 6:29 pmI am optimistic, actually. I was down on their choice of manager for a while, but I think the clean sweep in the dugout might refresh everything. Maybe there is leadership potential I don't see, and the new coaching staff can get our reliable bats, swinging again. If they can help Raleigh, Julio, and Naylor regain their form, then we could add another 5-7 wins to last year's record. Add Suzuki's and Garcia's defense, and that saves us another 3 or 4 games. If they sign Burger, and he hits Burger Bombs, our DH could net us another 2-3 games. The arrival and Anderson and Sloan (and the loss of Castillo and Miller) could be another few games. Suddenly, the confluence of roster upgrades nets us 10-15 more wins than last season (conservatively). Hello, AL West pennant.DavidGee24 wrote: ↑Fri Nov 20, 2026 6:24 pm
Very well said, Maple. If we sign Suzuki in addition to acquiring Garcia, with bounceback seasons from Raleigh and Naylor we look a lot better on paper. I'd be a bit wary of Burger, although if we end up having to settle on him it's better than what we usually settle on.
How much better we really get also depends on the bullpen. Management can't half-ass this - they need to g out and sign 2, maybe 3 dominant to elite arms. I know this is not their style, but they need to bolster the bullpen, especially the back end.
This could be a World Series roster with just a few more big moves ("big" by our standards. Pedestrian by Dodgers or Mets standards).