Captain 97 wrote: ↑Mon Oct 11, 2021 8:47 pm
ice99 wrote: ↑Mon Oct 11, 2021 8:25 pm
ice99 wrote: ↑Mon Oct 11, 2021 6:26 pm
Let me preface this by saying to take these WAR estimates with a grain of salt.
As a baseline with no moves (other than Seager buyout), the lineup looks something like:
JP, SS, 3.0 WAR
France, 1B, 3.5
Haniger, RF, 3.0
Toro, 2B, 2.0
Kelenic, CF, 2.0
Murphy, C, 1.5
Fraley, LF, 1.5
Torrens, DH, 1.0
Moore, 3B, 0
Current lineup, 17.5 WAR.
If they sign Gausman, then
Gausman, 4.0
Marco, 3.0
Flexen, 3.0
Gilbert, 3.0
Dunn/Sheffield/Brash/Kikuchi, 1.0
Rotation 14 WAR
According to Fangraphs top bullpen in terms of WAR was the Rays at 7.9 WAR. The M's came in at 7.0 WAR. I'm predicting some gain at 7.5 WAR.
A zero WAR team is supposed to be good for 47.7 wins. Give the bench 0.3 WAR.
This gives a baseline with Gausman is 87 wins.
Adding Semien (est. 4 WAR) allows Toro to move off 2B to 3B, displacing Moore. This brings it up to 91 wins.
I like bpj's idea of getting Schwarber (est. 2.5 WAR), which would upgrade Torrens and project the total to 92.5 wins.
The entire lineup this year had 11.5 fWAR They are losing Seager and you think they are going to put up 17.5 without any additions? That seems pretty optimistic. Ditto on the Rotation. they put up 7.3 WAR. You are losing Anderson who gave you 0.7 and adding 4 from Gausman which means you need to get 3.4 extra WAR spread out among the other 4 rotation spots to meet your projection of 14. Your projections would require just about everything to go right. No regression from anyone and most guys improving.
The M's aren't going to be a contending team if Kelenic, Toro, JP, France don't take large jumps offensively. The rebuild is predicated on that.
I'm expecting:
Kelenic: .250/.340/.470 +
Toro: .270/.350/430 +
Crawford: .280/.360/.400 +
France: .300/.380/.460 +
That's what the M's are going to need from these guys to take a big leap forward.
That's what the White Sox, Astros, Red Sox etc. get out of the majority of their players.
If these guys take big leaps like the organization is expecting, then we'll see a huge jump in WAR throughout our lineup and we'll actually be a real ballclub. If not, we're just spinning our wheels.